(High-ticket product, better price & rating but getting crushed)
Hey everyone,
I’m going head-to-head with a competitor on the exact same high-ticket product, and I’m stumped by how consistent their ad positioning is.
Quick breakdown:
-
Competitor: $119.99, 4.3 stars, 800 reviews
-
Me: $99.99, 4.5 stars, 250 reviews
-
Plenty of cheaper listings exist, but they still dominate BSR and sales
I’ve tracked their placements for weeks:
-
Every core keyword — big head terms and smaller ones — they hold TOP 1–2 ad position
-
Organic ranking is also consistently #1
-
ABA shows they own the #1 spot for almost all high-volume keywords
I’ve already confirmed top-of-search converts way better for this product, but CPC is intense. My budget isn’t unlimited, so I need to be sharp with how I spend.
Here’s what I’ve tried:
-
Started with down-only bidding, low base CPC, 100% top boost → barely got any clicks
-
Switched to fixed bidding, but still ~50% of clicks go to product pages
-
Should I lower base CPC even more and push top boost to 150%? Or will I just lose all impressions?
My biggest questions for the community:
-
How are they holding top position this reliably? Is it exact-match locking? Are they doing it with phrase/broad too?
-
Where should I put most of my budget: core exact-match keywords or phrase/broad?
-
What actual bidding + placement setup actually locks top positions without wasting spend?
I use third-party tools to monitor ranks, and their CPCs are clearly aggressive. I want to lock TOP 1–3 on my main keywords, but I’m not sure on bid and boost levels to get there without blowing ACOS.
Any real-world experience would be huge. Thanks.
Answers (10)
I started adding top boosts to phrase/broad too, but clicks dropped a lot.
Budget is ~$200–300/day, high profit pressure. How to allocate most efficiently?
Your phrase/broad ACOS is likely leaking money. Negate aggressively, but carefully.
Focusing budget on top *will* lower total clicks — Amazon won’t give one seller all frontpage real estate.
Try SBV video ads — they often perform well for high-ticket with lower ACOS.
For a mature product:
To lock top position:
Start low and tweak until you hit the position you want. Lowering base and raising top will reduce non-top clicks — that’s a good thing.
Test boosts gradually. Move high-converters from broad/phrase into exact. Non-top clicks are lower-quality anyway. Organic is what lowers long-term ad cost.
And should I really shift almost everything to exact? My profit is tight.
I don’t think it’s black hat. I just can’t explain the consistency. Focusing on ad structure first.
I run a product exactly like this competitor. Here’s the exact setup that holds top position:
It’s not cheap, but it locks the spot and keeps organic high. Basically, you pay “rank tax” to hold your position. If someone challenges, I just bump bids.
And do you put most budget into exact match? I’ve been splitting and feel unfocused.
This isn’t just “locking” — it’s listing weight + budget + margin.
They have a higher price, so more profit to spend on CPC. They outbid everyone, dominate ad positions, get more ad sales, which lifts organic, which makes their ads perform even better. Amazon favors them because they convert on those terms.
Your listing is solid, but if you can’t match their ad spend on head terms, you’ll get pushed around. How close is your organic rank?